Join the Ward 4 Email List!

Sunday, December 23, 2012

Community Favors Compatible Building Heights


NORMAN — Editor, The Transcript:
In your Dec. 18 news article titled “High-density zoning district currently under construction,” I was accurately characterized as “adamant” about a three-story height limit on Campus Corner for new residential development. The article, however, did not have the space to explain how I carefully arrived at this position.
First, a preference for three-story heights on Campus Corner is the strongly held opinion of our community. The city invited the entire community and our development partners to six dialogues on what high-density housing means, where it might be located, how it might look and how it might affect parking, infrastructure and traffic.
At the sixth and final dialogue, attendees expressed their opinions using a voting system devised by the city. This vote demonstrated that our community favors a three-story height limit on Campus Corner by a factor of 3 to 1. The city’s final report sums it up nicely: “Participants were nearly unanimous in their declaration that overly large buildings in the wrong locations are undesirable.”
Second, numerous architects have come forward to say unequivocally that a three-story height limit is right for Campus Corner. These individuals are actively engaged in development projects in the core area and know this is feasible for their industry.
One such architect described the prospect of designing new higher-density housing for Campus Corner as “exciting.” A second asked that new projects honor the Campus Corner landmarks of Whitehand Hall and McFarlin Church.
The six-story buildings (75 feet tall) preferred by our partners in the development community simply are not compatible with the architecture and “sense of place” on Campus Corner.
Third, a reasonable height limit is the conservative approach to altering Campus Corner. No one can say what the future holds. So, a three-story height limit is our best initial approach. After sufficient time has passed to gauge the effectiveness of this policy, the community can revisit the decision and increase the limit if needed.
GREG JUNGMAN
(published on December 23rd, in The Norman Transcript)

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

How Tall is 75 Feet?

(Background: The Norman, OK community is creating a new zoning category to allow high density residential development.  A key sticking point is how tall is too tall for residential buildings on historic Campus Corner? During a committee meeting on Dec 17, developers asked for a 75' height allowance.  The community asks for a 3-story limit)

Even in context, this question is rather difficult to answer (and ridiculous upon first inspection).  But the question is also critical.  We are told by our development partners that 75 feet is the point of feasibility, and we need to allow development on campus corner to reach this height.  Our community, through representatives at our 12-17 committee meeting and our high density dialogues wants compatible development.  Compatibility is achieved with much lower height limit (3 stories is proposed).  Why is compatibility impossible with the "feasible" limit of 75 feet?



I found the graphic above by simply "Googling" the title of this post.  The graphic shows a fake tree/cell tower next to a one story home.  Funny right?  Since many  places on Campus Corner are one story (my favorite sushi place, the Coltrane Property office, and Hideaway Pizza, and many more), this is a great comparison for our current dilemma.  Now in your mind, replace the tree with a large square building that extends off the screen to the right....

Bottom line :  we have a debate between: (1) the developers wishes for feasible rules... meaning rules that allow maximum flexibility and maximum bottom line, and (2) the community's desire for compatible development that enhances the sense of place and quality on Campus Corner.  Which standard is good for our community as whole?

What do you think?

GREG

Friday, December 14, 2012

High Density Housing is Ramping Up. A Proposal Moves Forward.


A six story, 200+ unit, high density housing proposal to be located on Asp Avenue will be presented to the Norman City Council for approval on January 8, 2013.

An ordinance to govern high density housing is NOT complete.  In fact, a new draft of such an ordinance is due to the Planning and Transportation Committee on Monday, December 17 (please join us at 5:30pm at City Hall for this meeting).  The draft ordinance still needs revisions, and a joint meeting of the committee and our Planning Commissioners is planned.  While we are getting very close to a new zoning category on this subject, we are not yet complete.

Key Facts for January 8 (a Mark Risser project):
O On November 16th, Mark Risser of Dallas, TX,  will bring forward a rezoning request for property generally located at Asp Avenue and Duffy Street
O Mr. Risser requests a C-3 Zoning (Intensive Commercial District) with a Special Use for a Mixed Building (in my opinion this category is not intended to allow high density housing)
O This zoning comes with no height restrictions and permits "one or more dwelling units on the upper floors"
O Mr. Risser proposes approximately 200 units in six stories at a height of 72 feet
O Should Risser be asked to bring this proposal in under the new rules, it would likely be disallowed for its design and height.

Regardless of how you feel about high density housing, I hope you will agree that completing our community process of crafting an ordinance should occur first.  Approving any project at this point would simply put the cart before the horse and dishonor all the hard work of citizens during the high density discussion series.

Key Facts for December 17 Committee Meeting (5:30pm, Norman City Hall):
O The latest draft of the High Density zoning rule will be presented and discussed at 5:30pm on 12/17.  The draft rule is available via our Facebook group or by emailing me.
O ***Key points of the draft violate what was determined in the high density dialogues. Height limits have increased 66%. Unit densities have increased 20%. Parking rules are reduced by nearly half.***
O The draft policy allows a five story building height on Campus Corner and a seven story height in Downtown.
O The requirement for location on an arterial street is removed (a project may be up to 2 blocks away from an artery on a collector street)
O The draft policy contains strong language on design. Example: "Long unbroken facades with no offsets or articulations are not allowed".
O How design guidelines will be enforced is not clear.  Will the city staff require developers to alter plans?  Will all plans simply proceed to council?
O Please join us at City Hall at 5:30 pm on Monday, December 17, 2012 to see what happens next.

I hope to see you at City Hall.

Warm Regards,

Greg

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

The Norman Transcript (November 14, 2012): Chickens!


The Norman City Council gladly approved chicken raising for urban residents on November 13, 2012.  With so many residents already raising "backyard chickens", this change simply makes good sense.  


Not mentioned in the article below ... Edwin Kessler of Rosemont Drive admonished Council on two occasions that "regulating" chickens was largely non-sense.  Dr. Kessler has a long history with chickens in Norman and elsewhere; his experience is that chickens create zero nuance and are cared for by their owners out of common sense.  Dr. Kessler noted that if an owner cares to keep chickens, providing water and shelter from predators is required by nature and city rules add nothing. Well said, sir.

**********
By Joy Hampton
Eating local is taking on a whole new meaning in Norman. The city council approved an ordinance amendment that allows up to four chickens in residential neighborhoods where they were previously prohibited.
Roosters will not be allowed.
Supporters say chickens are an investment and owners will take good care of them.
“We love our chickens,” Norman resident Kim Frakes said “They are a part of our family.”
Frakes said that she lives on a corner lot that backs up to a creek and is already able to have chickens on her property.
The new ordinance expands the chicken allowance to smaller lots, which are zoned R-1.
“The ordinance would apply throughout the city, but if you had restrictive covenants, they would apply,” said city attorney Jeff Bryant, adding that covenants supersede the ordinance.
City Planner Susan Connors said health issues were taken into consideration when developing the ordinance. Smell also was taken into consideration, which is why the number of chickens was limited to four. Complaints related to chickens and chicken coops will be handled by animal control.
“The idea for this wasn’t just plucked out of the air,” Council member Tom Kovach said.
He said residents asked for this as a means of developing a local food source.
“This has been done in cities all over the world with much denser populations than ours,” Kovach said.
Council member Dave Spaulding gave advice on the care and raising of chickens, including the use of droppings as fertilizer. Only Council member Roger Gallagher voted against the ordinance amendment.
Norman’s Municipal Code had required that chicken enclosures be at least 100 feet from the nearest dwelling other than the owner’s and 25 feet from the nearest property line, but “proponents of urban chickens” said those restrictions limited chickens to agricultural zones or large residential estates, according to city staff reports.
The driving forces of the urban chicken movement include the move toward local food sources, poultry recalls and environmental sustainability.
The chickens must be kept within a designated chicken coop and chicken run, and the coop cannot be in the front yard or side yards. The coop and run can be no closer than five feet from property lines and no closer than 25 feet from the neighbor’s house. Movable chicken enclosures are permitted within those distance guidelines.
The minimum size for a chicken coop is four-square-feet per animal, and the chicken run must be eight-square-feet per animal. During daylight hours, chickens must have access to a chicken run and a chicken coop but may be kept within the coop from dusk until dawn as protection against predators. Coops must be predator resistant, and enclosures must be screened to keep flies and vermin out.
“Water shall be provided on site and accessible to chickens at all times,” according to the ordinance. “All chicken enclosures shall be cleaned regularly to prevent an accumulation of food, fecal matter or nesting material from creating a nuisance or unsanitary condition due to odor, vermin, debris or decay.
“Outdoor slaughter of chickens is prohibited,” according to the ordinance.

Friday, November 2, 2012

Economic Development: Norman Has a Plan

On November 1, 2012, the Business and Community Affairs Committee of the Norman City Council considered a draft economic development policy.  The committee looked favorably upon the policy with the exception of me.  The role of lonely (somewhat exhausted skeptic) fell to me once again.  All BS aside, here is what I don't like about our current policy:

1.  The words "cash" and "city paid" are littered throughout the policy.  My colleagues advised me not worry about this since we don't have a source of funds.  Staff advised that they don't envision cash payments.  No one agreed to take the language out.  Consequently, there is nothing to prevent us from using existing funds.

2.  There is nothing restrictive in the policy whatsoever.  This is a problem.  We will be negotiating with companies to locate in Norman.  They will want things.  As it stands with this policy, nothing is off limits.  Sales tax, property tax, permit fees, permit processing time, city staff support, and other benefits are all ON the table.  In the heat of the deal is the worst time to decide what you WON'T give up.

3.  There are no clawbacks in the policy.  Yes, the entire committee agrees that clawbacks are necessary (this is good), but since they are not in our policy they will be up for negotiation in each deal.  How much pressure will there be to leave them out?  When negotiations are intense and jobs are on the line, will we hold fast to clawbacks?

4. Overall, we have kicked the can very far down the road.  We are headed to the car dealership with no idea of how much we want to spend or what kind of car we need.  The dealer will roll out the Super Size SUV with double bells and extra whistles ... how much will we pay for the privilege of owning it?  No funds, forgiveness, or exemption is off limits....

Now, let's be fair.  I have been encouraged to take a more balanced view of things on City Council.  As an academic exercise, I am game.  Three reasons why this might work out:

1.  It is possible to make a deal and pay nothing out of pocket.  NEDA (which is really just an instrument to carry debt, which is illegal for the city to do) might simply issue revenue bonds that can be paid back with revenues of the project or revenues of another government incentive program.  This might create jobs in exchange for the city accepting risk plus forgone revenues --this price is not too high if everything goes as planned.  (Of course, if the company goes belly up and the NEDA defaults on the debt ... the banks will coming knocking on the city's door)

2.  There is considerable deliberation designed in to the process.  We plan to have an Economic Development Advisory Board (EDAB) of "experts" (some of whom will simply be practitioners) to advise us on both the quality of deals offered and the performance of deals made.  Then, the NEDA (City Council) can further review the deal or performance question.  This could be enough process to keep things from getting out of control.  (Mind you, we don't have any rules, yet, to prevent us from skipping steps and fast tracking deals ... there will certainly be pressure to move quickly).  Decisions might be made in an environment rich in information (assuming misinformation is not rampant).

3.  On its face, the goal is good --ensure good jobs are available in Norman.  A former City Council Member suggested our economy was too heavy in public sector employment.  While some may agree as a political preference, the benefit of a heavily public sector workforce is stability.  The university, the hospital, our public schools are all largely avoided the disaster of the Great Recession.

Take care and send questions,
Greg
Ward4@NormanOK.gov

Friday, October 26, 2012

Keeping Our Word

I would like to thank you my colleagues for unanimously supporting the motion to reject the Elsey Partners' request to develop high density residential housing on Boyd Street.  I would also like to thank the members of our community that came forward to voice their opinion on the matter. 

From The Oklahoman:

... the [high density residential] policies are not ready yet, said Councilman Greg Jungman, “and we've committed to our residents that we would develop guidelines. We owe it to them to complete that commitment before approving any request for high-density developments.”

Full Article by Jane Cannon

 — 
City council members say they are not ready to approve a Kansas developer's plans to build a high-rise, student-oriented apartment building near Campus Corner.


The council voted unanimously Tuesday to reject a request from Chris Elsey, of Elsey Partners of Manhattan, Kan., to create a special planning district for a block of land between Boyd and McCullough streets from Monnett Avenue to the Boyd Street railroad tracks.
Elsey said the location is ideal for a high-density housing project that would promote “walkability” to the Campus Corner retail district and the University of Oklahoma campus.

He wants to construct a six-story, 75-foot building with 250 two-bedroom apartments on five levels, with an interior parking garage on the ground level. Conceivably, the building could house more than 500 people.

Norman's zoning ordinances do not allow for such a development, limiting housing density to 26 dwelling units per acre, Planning Director Susan Connors said. Elsey's project calls for upward of 100 dwelling units per acre.

City planners are working on setting policies for that type of project, because developers increasingly are bringing such proposals to them, Connors said.

But the policies are not ready yet, said Councilman Greg Jungman, “and we've committed to our residents that we would develop guidelines. We owe it to them to complete that commitment before approving any request for high-density developments.”
Creating a special planning district would be the only way under current zoning ordinances to accommodate what Elsey wants to do, Connors said.

To approve Elsey's request would be “putting the horse before the cart,” Mayor Cindy Rosenthal said. “We've got a land-use change suggested with no zoning request accompanying it so we can see what we would be getting. It's like being asked to write a blank check.”

Resident Cheryl Clayton said the mass and size of the building being proposed is out of proportion to its Campus Corner surroundings and would have an adverse effect on traffic, as well as aesthetics.

Elsey said he has built similar high-rise apartment buildings near Kansas State University in Manhattan and Oklahoma State University in Stillwater, and such projects are in demand because of growing student populations.

Rosenthal said Elsey's pictures “don't resemble anything like we talked about” in a series of public meetings held in June on high-density developments. At those meetings, residents looked at designs that incorporated unusual architectural elements and often featured high-rise apartments combined with retail establishments.

Councilman Jim Griffith said he was “excited” about the possibilities of mixed-use, high-density developments but couldn't support giving Elsey's project the go-ahead until guidelines for such projects are in place. He said Elsey could resubmit his project for approval later.

From the source: http://newsok.com/norman-city-council-rejects-high-density-housing-proposal/article/3721952#ixzz2APYOkgQp



Thursday, October 18, 2012

Developers are coming before City Council to ask approval of high density housing projects on Campus Corner.

Key Facts for October 23:

O October 23rd, the Elsey Partners of Manhattan, KS bring forward a proposal on Boyd at the RR tracks
O This proposal was postponed in the spring to make time for new rules on high density
O The proposed project includes approximately 300 units and is five to six stories tall

The Elsey proposal is a little different than your standard development deal.  On October 23, Elsey Partners request only an amendment or our 2025 Land Use Plan.  The amendment would create a special planning area on the "block" bound by Boyd, Monnett, McCullough, and the RR Tracks.  The special planning area would come with a special set of rules for future development that are likely unique to this area (and do not reflect our new high density zoning rules, which are forthcoming).  Then, at a later date Elsey Partners would come back to Council requesting a PUD to build their 300-unit (approx) apartment complex.

Key Facts for November 13:

O On November 16th, Mark Risser of Dallas, TX,  will bring forward a rezoning request for property generally located at Asp Avenue and Duffy Street
O Mr. Risser requests a C-3 Zoning (Intensive Commercial District) with a Special Use for a Mixed Building
O This zoning comes with no height restrictions and permits "one or more dwelling units on the upper floors"
O Mr. Risser proposes approximately 200 units in six stories at a height of 72 feet.
O The requested zoning change would permit Mr. Risser to change his plans at any point so long as he retained a commercial use on the first floor.  Mr. Risser or future owners could increase the height of the building or eliminate parking as a matter of right.

The image below is provided (I am told) by Mr. Risser as a theoretical representation of his proposal.  The picture is not drawn to scale as McFarlin seems to tower over the complex.  When in fact the apartment complex is approximately the same height as the church.


Regardless of how you feel about high density housing, I hope you will agree that completing our community process of crafting an ordinance should occur first.  Approving any project at this point would simply put the cart before the horse.