Join the Ward 4 Email List!

Friday, November 2, 2012

Economic Development: Norman Has a Plan

On November 1, 2012, the Business and Community Affairs Committee of the Norman City Council considered a draft economic development policy.  The committee looked favorably upon the policy with the exception of me.  The role of lonely (somewhat exhausted skeptic) fell to me once again.  All BS aside, here is what I don't like about our current policy:

1.  The words "cash" and "city paid" are littered throughout the policy.  My colleagues advised me not worry about this since we don't have a source of funds.  Staff advised that they don't envision cash payments.  No one agreed to take the language out.  Consequently, there is nothing to prevent us from using existing funds.

2.  There is nothing restrictive in the policy whatsoever.  This is a problem.  We will be negotiating with companies to locate in Norman.  They will want things.  As it stands with this policy, nothing is off limits.  Sales tax, property tax, permit fees, permit processing time, city staff support, and other benefits are all ON the table.  In the heat of the deal is the worst time to decide what you WON'T give up.

3.  There are no clawbacks in the policy.  Yes, the entire committee agrees that clawbacks are necessary (this is good), but since they are not in our policy they will be up for negotiation in each deal.  How much pressure will there be to leave them out?  When negotiations are intense and jobs are on the line, will we hold fast to clawbacks?

4. Overall, we have kicked the can very far down the road.  We are headed to the car dealership with no idea of how much we want to spend or what kind of car we need.  The dealer will roll out the Super Size SUV with double bells and extra whistles ... how much will we pay for the privilege of owning it?  No funds, forgiveness, or exemption is off limits....

Now, let's be fair.  I have been encouraged to take a more balanced view of things on City Council.  As an academic exercise, I am game.  Three reasons why this might work out:

1.  It is possible to make a deal and pay nothing out of pocket.  NEDA (which is really just an instrument to carry debt, which is illegal for the city to do) might simply issue revenue bonds that can be paid back with revenues of the project or revenues of another government incentive program.  This might create jobs in exchange for the city accepting risk plus forgone revenues --this price is not too high if everything goes as planned.  (Of course, if the company goes belly up and the NEDA defaults on the debt ... the banks will coming knocking on the city's door)

2.  There is considerable deliberation designed in to the process.  We plan to have an Economic Development Advisory Board (EDAB) of "experts" (some of whom will simply be practitioners) to advise us on both the quality of deals offered and the performance of deals made.  Then, the NEDA (City Council) can further review the deal or performance question.  This could be enough process to keep things from getting out of control.  (Mind you, we don't have any rules, yet, to prevent us from skipping steps and fast tracking deals ... there will certainly be pressure to move quickly).  Decisions might be made in an environment rich in information (assuming misinformation is not rampant).

3.  On its face, the goal is good --ensure good jobs are available in Norman.  A former City Council Member suggested our economy was too heavy in public sector employment.  While some may agree as a political preference, the benefit of a heavily public sector workforce is stability.  The university, the hospital, our public schools are all largely avoided the disaster of the Great Recession.

Take care and send questions,
Greg
Ward4@NormanOK.gov

No comments:

Post a Comment