Join the Ward 4 Email List!

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Picking Winners and Losers: The Pitfalls of Incentivizing Business and Industry

On the evening of April 23rd  your Norman City Council approved an economic development incentives policy and created the Economic Development Advisory Board to encourage businesses to choose Norman or expand in Norman.  The hope is that these firms will create jobs for Norman citizens and help our economy. The EDAB is specifically created to analyze the wisdom of doling out the incentives to private corporations such as cash, cash rebates, tax breaks, or other assistance.
In my view the policies needed some key improvements.  My reasons for these improvements were heard during the April 23 Council Meeting.  I truly appreciate my colleague’s commitment to listening.  The vigorous debate over my suggested changes demonstrated that my reasons were valid –in spite of being rejected.  I realize that this debate consumed much of people’s time and extended our Council meeting late into the evening.  I appreciate everyone’s patience.
For the record, my objections were two fold.  One, the new Economic Development Advisory Board and its authority to convene executive sessions creates a problem: lack of openness.  Sadly, I do not mean openness to the public, and I do not mean the board should avoid executive session.  The Oklahoma Statutes are somewhat peculiar in how they govern such private sessions.  A public body may hold one for various reasons, but members outside the public body are not eligible to “sit in” in all occasions.  Further, once an executive session is over there is no record of what transpired.  To resolve I asked that detailed written minutes be taken during these closed sessions.  This would allow members of the City Council to be informed of the discussions of the EDAB.  This would not open the process to public view --just to Council.  This suggestion was defeated 8 to 1. 
Secondly, I asked that our business recruiter-- the Norman Economic Development Coalition --be removed from the EDAB.  The ordinance includes one NEDC representative as an ex-officio member of the EDAB granting this person the right to join all sessions including executive sessions (but not vote).  The NEDC is guaranteed a seat at the table with EDAB, but Council Members do not enjoy the same right.  This is backwards, clearly. 
Further, the NEDC is asked to invite firms to Norman and encourage them to do business here.  To then ask NEDC if the firm should be provided an incentive is inappropriate.  In essence, NEDC will be grading their own work.  My amendment would have provided a clear separation of duties between recruiter and evaluator on any deal.  The amendment also harmed nothing –the EDAB could invite NEDC into any meeting it chose to, open or executive session. 
Lastly, the NEDC would benefit from the separation.  The NEDC, while publicly funded, has extensive private real estate holdings and assets.  The NEDC reported over $9 million in assets in its most recent financial statements.  Actual conflicts of interest would exist should NEDC choose to advise the EDAB on a firm with which NEDC had a partnership or financial interest.  This is unnecessary confusion for the public and bad policy for our city.  The suggestion failed 8 to 1.
I am genuinely afraid for our city on this issue.   So many cities have tried to play “the incentives game” with consequences ranging from neutral to disastrous.  I have seen zero evidence that incentives have enriched a city like ours.  Even incentives that seemingly harm nothing hurt the city by wasting valuable staff time and tying up public money or resources.  In at least one city, a local government declared bankruptcy over a failed incentive deal.  In many other cities, including those near us, public money has been spent with no discernible improvement in public well-being, financial or otherwise. 
For what it’s worth … the Norman City Council has promised to make better decisions than those councils and cities who failed.  We have pledged to be skeptics and carefully analyze every deal.  Hopefully, this comes to fruition, and Norman turns away every bad deal that comes our way.  Hopefully, we will know a bad deal when we see one.

Monday, April 22, 2013

High Density Compromise on the Table....

A remarkable shift in direction lead to some progress on the city's possible high density housing ordinance currently under consideration by the Community Planning and Transportation Committee.  Here is the run down:

The draft ordinance would create three categories of high density housing.  All categories would be required to produce a traffic impact analysis, submit to an infrastructure assessment by public works staff, and adhere to compatibility and quality design standards.  An architectural review board would help determine the merits of individual projects. The categories are as follows:

HD-1
This would be townhouses or row houses built in an urban fashion (no yard).  The developments would have a max height of 37 feet and a max density of 40 units per acre.  These projects would have flexible parking requirements within a 1 space per bedroom minimum.

HD-2
This would be apartment developments built with zero set back in a urban fashion similar to projects in OKC near Bricktown.  The projects would have a max height of 48 feet and a max density of 75 units per acre. These projects would include mandatory structured/integrated parking or parking fees payable to the city to provide for shared parking.  Commercial uses on the first floor will be encouraged dependent on location.

HD-3
This would be a high rise-type category allowing construction up to the max height for frame construction of 75 feet.  Max densities would be unlimited.   Commercial uses on the first floor(s) would be required to support active street scape.  A parking garage or integrated parking deck would be required with possible parking fees to cover additional parking needs.

What do you think?  I welcome your thoughts and feedback.  Next meeting: May 13th at 5:30pm.

GREG