Follow the link at bottom and you will find latest information on the Economic Development Advisory Board --the board that will advise the Norman Economic Development Trust Authority (NEDA). You know... the one approved on June 12th without any public discussion (Mayor Rosenthal, Council Member Gallagher, and C.M. Spaulding, only, voted in favor of a public discussion).
The current draft resolution only allows certain professions to sit on the EDAB (law, finance, accounting, or banking). The board would have just five members. Only three of the members would be appointed by an elected official (our Mayor); the remaining seats are controlled by the Chamber of Commerce and the NEDC (the NEDC is in turn partly controlled by the Chamber).
Send me your thoughts... Via our Facebook Group - Norman - Ward 4
.... or via email: mailto:jungman4ward4@gmail.com
Click below to read the draft ordinance and background info:
http://www.normanok.gov/sites/default/files/WebFM/Norman/City%20Manager/Council%20Business%20and%20Community%20Affairs%20Committee.pdf
To complete the discussion, here is the City Attorney's opinion on the ability of the NEDA and the EDAB to conduct business in executive session (fully outside the public view and not subject to Open Records). If you can't read thses (try clicking on them), let me know and I can email you a copy.
Join the Ward 4 Email List!
Saturday, June 30, 2012
Wednesday, June 27, 2012
Information on the Norman Economic Development Coalition (NEDC)
If you are not familiar with the Norman Economic Development Coalition, here is some information.
You can visit their website: http://www.nedcok.com. From the "About Us" section of their website ...
You can view their Q1 Report for 2012 (financial statements included): http://www.4shared.com/office/-QHQvnA-/1st_Quarter_-_Minutes_and_Fina.html The link will take to 4shared.com, where you can download the report. It's a 2MB pdf (its safe!).
The City of Norman provides $125,000.00 per year to the NEDC. The University, the Sooner Centurions (similar to Chamber of Commerce), and the Moore-Norman Vo-Tech also contribute to the group's funding.
You can visit their website: http://www.nedcok.com. From the "About Us" section of their website ...
The Norman Economic Development Coalition is dedicated to
expanding the economic base of the Norman community, enhancing the
earning opportunities of area residents by retaining and expanding
existing businesses and industries, as well as attracting desirable
new employers that are consistent with Norman's high quality of
life.
Established in 1996, the Norman Economic Development Coalition (NEDC)
is a joint effort of the University of Oklahoma, the City of Norman,
Moore Norman Technology Center, and the Sooner Centurions, a
committee of the Norman Chamber of Commerce. This unique partnership was formed to work full time on economic development in the Norman community.
Primary Areas of Activity:
- Support business retention and the expansion of locally based employment centers
- Support business creation and technology commercialization
- Support needed product improvements including specific business climate and infrastructure changes
You can view their Q1 Report for 2012 (financial statements included): http://www.4shared.com/office/-QHQvnA-/1st_Quarter_-_Minutes_and_Fina.html The link will take to 4shared.com, where you can download the report. It's a 2MB pdf (its safe!).
The City of Norman provides $125,000.00 per year to the NEDC. The University, the Sooner Centurions (similar to Chamber of Commerce), and the Moore-Norman Vo-Tech also contribute to the group's funding.
Tuesday, June 26, 2012
Pitfalls of Economic Development
A great article on the pitfalls of publicly-funded economic development proposals.
The article closes, "... process matters. Economic development is an important function of our state and local government, but it is also one of the most easily abused. Business executives, accustomed to more control of decisions within their own companies, may be frustrated by the politics. But they need to realize that the use of public funds requires a more open and careful deliberation. It’s not quick or easy, but it’s an important part of democratic governance."
Click here to read the full article: http://okpolicy.org/blog/economy/it-matters-who-guards-the-henhouse/
The article closes, "... process matters. Economic development is an important function of our state and local government, but it is also one of the most easily abused. Business executives, accustomed to more control of decisions within their own companies, may be frustrated by the politics. But they need to realize that the use of public funds requires a more open and careful deliberation. It’s not quick or easy, but it’s an important part of democratic governance."
Click here to read the full article: http://okpolicy.org/blog/economy/it-matters-who-guards-the-henhouse/
Sunday, June 17, 2012
Letter to the Editor: Professor Cynthia Rogers writes about proper pricing of impact fees
Elephant roaming Norman
NORMAN — Editor, The Transcript:The recent debates at city hall (NTIFA, NEDA, the north water treatment plant and high-density housing) are examples where various agents are looking at different sides of the same elephant: “Who pays for growth?”
If cost of growth was properly accounted for, then citizens would have no reason to oppose new development for fear of increased tax prices for city services. Rather, fees that reflect the overall (true) cost of new development would lead to growth determined by market forces.
If impact fees are too low, citizens end up subsidizing new development via higher taxes and/or degraded quality of public services, which leads to faster growth than would otherwise occur. If impact fees are too high, then new development would proceed too slowly. Norman has a sewer impact fee (e.g., the sewer excise tax) of $2,450 for a 2,000-square-foot home. Do Norman’s impact fees reflect the true costs of new development?
There are two reasons to think that Norman’s impact fees are inadequate. First, the fee has not been changed since it was established in 2001. Adjusted for inflation, the value of $2,450 in 2001 was $3,022 in 2010.
Second, compared with other cities that address growth costs via impact fee schemes, Norman’s impact fees are minimal. According to Mullen’s 2011 National Impact Fee Survey, Norman’s sewer impact fee was one third that of the average ($3,692) for a three-bedroom, 2,000-square-foot home in surveyed communities, excluding California. (The survey is available at www.impactfees.com/publications%20pdf/2011_survey.pdf).
Furthermore, the vast majority of surveyed communities have multiple impact fees, including transportation, drain, fire, parks, police, schools and water. Norman’s single impact fee amounts to about 20 percent of the total impact fees for surveyed communities, excluding California.
It is clear that Norman is behind the ball in terms of properly assessing the costs of growth. According to economic principles, until the pricing mechanism (related to new development) is corrected, Norman is unlikely to achieve optimal growth. We can’t establish an effective growth policy without first dealing with the elephant roaming our town: The costs of growth.
Cynthia Rogers
Associate professor, Department of Economics, University of Oklahoma
Saturday, June 16, 2012
A Letter to the Editor from the Mayor, June 16, 2012
A shameful beginning for the NEDA
NORMAN — Editor, The Transcript:Public concern about the recent adoption of the trust indenture for a Norman Economic Development Authority (NEDA) focuses around the adequacy of public input and debate in the process.
On Tuesday, when a number of Norman citizens had waited more than four hours to speak on the item, the city council by a 6-3 vote summarily cut off any information — no staff report on the most recent version, no council comment and no opportunity for the public to speak.
Several of the proponents of censoring public debate cited what they considered adequate public discussion. Specifically, it was noted that the trust indenture had been “in the public domain for comment for well over a month” and under consideration by a council committee since 2011. It is extremely important to examine the claim of adequate public input and compare this debate to other controversial issues that have come before the council.
The idea of creating a public trust was identified as a future agenda item at the first meeting of the Business and Community Affairs Committee (BACA) in August 2011. In the seven subsequent BACA meetings, the trust indenture was discussed four times, sometimes only briefly in the one-hour committee meetings. Importantly, those untelevised committee meetings are at 9 a.m. Thursdays, where the opportunity for the public to participate, or even attend, is somewhat limited.
A televised city council study session occurred March 27, at which a number of concerns and questions were raised by council members, and the direction was given to hold a public forum to solicit citizen input. By the so-called “rule of three,” the trust indenture was pre-emptively placed on the council agenda for May 8, with essentially three working-days notice to the public.
Because of intense public outcry, the item was then postponed until June 12 and a public forum held May 29, where many questions were raised from citizens, both pro and con. Another BACA meeting was hosted June 7 to make further revisions, resulting in the proposal on the agenda five days later.
Contrast this level of public participation with two other topics that are surrounded by controversy. The recently launched consideration of high-density development is being considered in six public forums, which will be followed by numerous committee meetings, Planning Commission consideration and other council meetings.
Consider also the role that public participation played in the development of the Storm Water Master Plan (SWMP) and the subsequent storm water ordinance for “water quality protection zones” (WQPZ). Over a three-and-a-half-year period, the SWMP had a broad-based citizen task force that met 11 times, six public forums were held, individual ward meetings were convened, and multiple presentations were made before the Greenbelt Commission and to civic groups.
On the WQPZ ordinance alone, an additional five meetings were convened of the citizen task force to discuss the ordinance, many meetings were held with developer and chamber-related groups, two public hearings were held before the Planning Commission and written notice was given to more than 13,584 Norman property owners.
At the city council meeting where the ordinance and SWMP were adopted, extensive public input was allowed and amendments offered, explained and voted on by the full council.
Some people still criticize whether public input was sufficient on the storm water issues, and I respect their view. Nonetheless, the consideration given to NEDA certainly pales by comparison.
What occurred this week to stifle public debate is unprecedented. In my eight years on city council, I can recall only two occasions when there was a request to “call the previous question” and cut off debate. Both of these motions came after the council entertained and listened to public discussion for several hours before taking action on the agenda item.
As I stated Tuesday evening, the NEDA needs public support and transparency if it is to be successful. We are clearly off to a disappointing and shameful start.
CINDY ROSENTHAL
Norman mayor
A stark and welcome contrast to the views of the Ward 2 Council Member, which you can read here: http://tomkovach.com/69/the-public-was-heard/
Thursday, June 14, 2012
Hal Ezell Invokes the Nuclear Option
The City Council Meeting for June 12, 2012 is available at the link below.
http://normanok.granicus.com/MediaPlayer.php?view_id=2&clip_id=411
Scrub ahead to 3:55:00 for the NEDA "Debate" (or lack thereof).
=GREG
http://normanok.granicus.com/MediaPlayer.php?view_id=2&clip_id=411
Scrub ahead to 3:55:00 for the NEDA "Debate" (or lack thereof).
=GREG
Monday, June 4, 2012
Editorial: Groups spreading misinformation about plant
Appeared in The Norman Transcript on Sun Jun 03, 2012
NORMAN —
Editor, The Transcript:
According to the Transcript, the City Council is under some pressure from the Norman Developers Council and the Builders Association demanding that the remainder of the temporary sales tax (fund 323), some $6 million, be diverted to begin construction of a North Treatment Plant in the Lake Thunderbird watershed. - Even though the City’s own legal department has made it clear that the City is under no obligation to invest that money in a North treatment plant, these interest groups persist in a campaign of disinformation in order to force the city to build a facility for which there is no legitimate or economic justification. - The developers, in a letter from their attorney, have now threatened the City Council that they will not support the Transportation Bond Package unless the North plant is included in the budget. - There is no confusion on the council or in the public mind as to the latitude given the council to make prudent decisions by the referendums concerning the temporary sales tax. - There is no public demand for a do-over referendum. The Transcript article further made clear that, in response to developers’ empty threats, the city attorney is negotiating with developers a deal to “set aside” the remaining $6 million for a North plant sometime in the future. - As you must know, if that happens, utility customers will have to make up the difference through higher than necessary rates to complete the mandatory upgrades at the current plant. This is unacceptable. - A sewer rate increase, voted on by the citizens, will be necessary to fund the SWWTP project. Whether or not it passes may well depend on how the temporary sales tax fund will be used. - If all the remaining $6 million from the temporary sales tax fund are not dedicated to the SWWTP project, the rate increase will be higher than necessary and citizens will likely reject it. - This could have serious repercussions for developers. Since Norman could soon be in violation of the Clean Water Act, a building moratorium is not out of the question. - We should also add that the excise tax on new construction is now over 10 years old. - It appears not to be adequate. It would be appropriate to consider an increase of that tax along with any rate increase proposal. -
Signed
Sandra Rose -
Charles Wesner -
Marian Hutchison -
Ben Alpers -
Glen Brown -
Mary Francis -
Gail Poole -
Lyntha Wesner -
David Morgan -
Libba Smith -
Margaret Farmer -
Chad Cox -
Tom Fredgren -
Jayne Crumpley -
Cynthia L. Rogers
Editor, The Transcript:
According to the Transcript, the City Council is under some pressure from the Norman Developers Council and the Builders Association demanding that the remainder of the temporary sales tax (fund 323), some $6 million, be diverted to begin construction of a North Treatment Plant in the Lake Thunderbird watershed. - Even though the City’s own legal department has made it clear that the City is under no obligation to invest that money in a North treatment plant, these interest groups persist in a campaign of disinformation in order to force the city to build a facility for which there is no legitimate or economic justification. - The developers, in a letter from their attorney, have now threatened the City Council that they will not support the Transportation Bond Package unless the North plant is included in the budget. - There is no confusion on the council or in the public mind as to the latitude given the council to make prudent decisions by the referendums concerning the temporary sales tax. - There is no public demand for a do-over referendum. The Transcript article further made clear that, in response to developers’ empty threats, the city attorney is negotiating with developers a deal to “set aside” the remaining $6 million for a North plant sometime in the future. - As you must know, if that happens, utility customers will have to make up the difference through higher than necessary rates to complete the mandatory upgrades at the current plant. This is unacceptable. - A sewer rate increase, voted on by the citizens, will be necessary to fund the SWWTP project. Whether or not it passes may well depend on how the temporary sales tax fund will be used. - If all the remaining $6 million from the temporary sales tax fund are not dedicated to the SWWTP project, the rate increase will be higher than necessary and citizens will likely reject it. - This could have serious repercussions for developers. Since Norman could soon be in violation of the Clean Water Act, a building moratorium is not out of the question. - We should also add that the excise tax on new construction is now over 10 years old. - It appears not to be adequate. It would be appropriate to consider an increase of that tax along with any rate increase proposal. -
Signed
Sandra Rose -
Charles Wesner -
Marian Hutchison -
Ben Alpers -
Glen Brown -
Mary Francis -
Gail Poole -
Lyntha Wesner -
David Morgan -
Libba Smith -
Margaret Farmer -
Chad Cox -
Tom Fredgren -
Jayne Crumpley -
Cynthia L. Rogers
What's Up This Week at City Hall (June 4 Edition)
Joy Hampton provides a run-down of what's going on at City Hall this week.
Big Event: Business & Community Affairs Committee Meeting on Thurs., June 7th at 9am at City Hall, where some will no doubt continue to tell us that the Norman Economic Development Authority is much needed --but they won't tell us why.
Article: http://normantranscript.com/headlines/x1595586434/Trust-authority-debate-continues
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

