Join the Ward 4 Email List!

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

TIME November 9, 1998: Corporate Welfare


A TIME investigation uncovers how hundreds of companies get on the dole--and why it costs every working American the equivalent of two weeks' pay every year


By Donald L. Barlett and James B. Steele

TIME magazine
(TIME, Nov. 9 [1998]) -- How would you like to pay only a quarter of the real estate taxes you owe on your home? And buy everything for the next 10 years without spending a single penny in sales tax? Keep a chunk of your paycheck free of income taxes? Have the city in which you live lend you money at rates cheaper than any bank charges? Then have the same city install free water and sewer lines to your house, offer you a perpetual discount on utility bills--and top it all off by landscaping your front yard at no charge?

Fat chance. You can't get any of that, of course. But if you live almost anywhere in America, all around you are taxpayers getting deals like this. These taxpayers are called corporations, and their deals are usually trumpeted as "economic development" or "public-private partnerships." But a better name is corporate welfare. 

The justification for much of this [corporate] welfare is that the U.S. government is creating jobs. Over the past six years, Congress appropriated $5 billion to run the Export-Import Bank of the United States, which subsidizes companies that sell goods abroad. 

State and local governments now give corporations money to move from one city to another--even from one building to another--and tax credits for hiring new employees. They supply funds to train workers or pay part of their wages while they are in training, and provide scientific and engineering assistance to solve workplace technical problems. They repave existing roads and build new ones. They lend money at bargain-basement interest rates to erect plants or buy equipment. They excuse corporations from paying sales and property taxes and relieve them from taxes on investment income.

This kind of arithmetic seldom adds up. Let's say the Philadelphia job pays $50,000. And each new worker pays $6,700 in local and state taxes. That means it will take nearly a half-century of tax collections from each individual to earn back the money granted to create his or her job. And that assumes all 950 workers will be recruited from outside Philadelphia and will relocate in the city, rather than move from existing jobs within the city, where they are already paying taxes.

If corporate welfare is an unproductive end game, why does it keep growing in a period of intensive government cost cutting? For starters, it has good p.r. and an army of bureaucrats working to expand it.  They have their own trade associations. They create attractive websites on the Internet. And they never call it "welfare." They call it "economic incentives" or "empowerment zones" or "enterprise zones."

Whatever the name, the result is the same. Some companies receive public services at reduced rates, while all others pay the full cost. Some companies are excused from paying all or a portion of their taxes due, while all others must pay the full amount imposed by law. Some companies receive grants, low-interest loans and other subsidies, while all others must fend for themselves.

In the end, that's corporate welfare's greatest flaw. It's unfair. One role of government is to help ensure a level playing field for people and businesses. Corporate welfare does just the opposite. It tilts the playing field in favor of the largest or the most politically influential or most aggressive businesses. In the next story, and those that follow in the coming weeks, you will meet the beneficiaries of corporate welfare--and the people who pay for it.


Thank you to Charles Wesner of Norman, OK for drawing my attention to this important article.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Economic Development Incentives: Can We Afford It? Should We Do It?

The morning of October 4, 2012, your City Council's Business and Community Affairs Committee engaged further discussions on a proposed ordinance that would provide incentives to certain businesses and corporations for locating to Norman.

Here are a few highlights:

O A business that brings jobs paying $33,000 per year would be eligible for cash, tax benefits, or other rewards for bringing "good jobs" to Norman. (For context, a family of three making this amount of money is eligible for free and/or reduced lunch in our school system.)

O Communities in neighboring states offer TIF incentives, tax abatement, cash, free rent, and other incentives to businesses. Norman is likely to incorporate one or all of these "tools" into our ordinance. This is real money or real debt.

Please weigh in on the Economic Development discussion. Our Norman Economic Development Authority (NEDA)has broad and powerful tools to both legally and politically to commit the city to expensive projects. I am afraid we are moving too quickly on this and without enough information.

While I don't exactly agree with this gentleman's ideas on Economic Development and tax abatement. I enjoyed the absurdity of the discussion. A clip of the City of Wichita:

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

August 28th: A Proud Day, Norman Approves Greenway Master Plan

There are so many people to thank, and since my involvement in the Greenway Master Plan and Greenbelt Commission is so limited, I don't even know who all to say "thank you" to.  So, let me thank everyone --everyone that pitched in along the way to create a plan that works for all of Norman.

This plan, an aspiration for our community, is one that has the blessing of every corner of our community.  The development community supports it.  Those who prioritize ecology and sustainability support it. And pretty much everyone in between is on board.

I also want to call particular attention to Council Member Dave Spaulding.  CM Spaulding and I may not always I agree, but I admire and respect Dave's openness to new information --even when that information may not jive with his deeply held beliefs.  This is the second time in less than a year that I have personally witnessed CM Spaulding listen to views not aligned with his own and find a way forward.  While CM Spaulding could not in the vote for the plan, he kindly withdrew his motion to further postpone its consideration.

Of course, we are only beginning our journey to fulfill the vision of our Greenbelt Commission.  The next step, finding resources to make the plan a reality, will require the city to redouble its efforts.  Groups with very different interests will have sit across the table and build upon the common ground established in this plan.  Taking this vision and making it a reality will not be easy, but nothing worthwhile ever is.

This is progress. Thank you, Norman.

Learn more about the Greenbelt Commission and the Greenway Master plan here:
http://normanok.gov/planning/greenbelt-commission

What is possible?  The City of Flagstaff, Arizona has an extensive system of urban, wild, bike, and hiking trails.  Check their system map: http://az-flagstaff3.civicplus.com/index.aspx?NID=1521

-GREG

Saturday, August 18, 2012

2012 Transportation Bond Election. You Decide!

On August 28th, you will decide if Norman engages in over $80 million of transportation projects (at a cost of just $40 million in bonds).  In this post you will find a video interview from Public Works Director Shawn O'Leary, some key facts, and a link to the City's information page.

Lastly, send me your questions.  It would be my pleasure to track down a good answer.  Many skeptics have been satisfied with the city's answers to their concerns.  Don't your skepticism go unexplored.  There are many reasons to support this bond program!


Key Facts:
O The bond is matched with $46.4 million in federal funds
O Project total: $89 million
O Widens Lindsey to 5 lanes from I-35 to Berry Road
O Constructs storm water improvements at Lindsey & McGee
O Widens parts of: 36th Avenue NW, 12th Avenue SE, East Alameda St... And more

Election: August 28, 2012

Early Voting (Cleveland County Election Board Office):  Friday, August 24th and Monday, August 27th

Learn More About the Bond Package:
Lindsey Street concept animation:
http://www.normanok.gov/content/conceptual-plan-widen-lindsey-street-berry-road-i-35

See an interview on this topic with Public Works Director Shawn O'Leary here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gwIU4zzoAH0&feature=player_embedded

Learn the details of the bond here:




Wednesday, August 15, 2012

August 14: Is it okay?

I was disappointed that Council decided to allow the Boyd/Monnet mixed used project to proceed in advance of the conclusion of our high density discussions.  It seems plain to me that a community would complete a dialogue that approaches its sixth and final meeting prior to giving the go-ahead to a project that impacts the very issues being discussed.  Is the density of this project lower than others proposed?  Yes.  Is the high density discussion series only about units per acre?  Absolutely not.

Is it okay?  I don't think so.

We are asked to believe that this is a MUD (mixed use development) and not "high density".  While the uses are certainly mixed, as I pointed out during the meeting this project meets neither the spirit nor the letter of the MUD zoning ordinance.  Perhaps the project is close enough to the MUD rules to be approved.  This may be true. But, it is not such a perfect MUD that we should permit ourselves to ignore the public discussions that very well may impact this project's final design.

The real tragedy is that this project, thoughtfully designed by Barrett Williamson and brought forward by a local investor, does so many things well.  This project would have been the perfect candidate for approval under our new rules.  The project hits a home run on on many things we will be asking other high density projects to do.  The building's height is reasonable, the density is not overly intensive, the exterior materials are 100% durable, and the parking provided is likely adequate.  We will be lucky if the other high density projects offer our community this type of quality.

Moving forward it is my hope that we will use the Boyd/Monnet project as a measuring stick for other proposals.  Let's require our investors from out of town to rise to the high standards of this project.  Specifically, we must demand reasonable building heights, 80 to 100% durable exterior materials, and concessions to neighbors who will be affected by the new construction.

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Ward Meeting: Transportation Bond Election


Thursday, August 16th at 5:30 p.m.

 join us at City Hall for ...

Ward 4 Meeting: Transportation Bond Election

City staff will be present to answer any and all questions!  This will be a joint ward meeting with our neighbors in Ward 2 and Ward 3!  

Election: August 28, 2012

See an interview on this topic with Public Works Director Shawn O'Leary here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gwIU4zzoAH0&feature=player_embedded


Key Facts:

O The bond is matched with $46.4 million in federal funds
O Project total: $89 million
O Widens Lindsey to 5 lanes from I-35 to Berry Road
O Constructs storm water improvements at Lindsey & McGee
O Widens parts of: 36th Avenue NW, 12th Avenue SE, East Alameda St... And more

Learn the details of the bond here: