I was disappointed that Council decided to allow the Boyd/Monnet mixed used project to proceed in advance of the conclusion of our high density discussions. It seems plain to me that a community would complete a dialogue that approaches its sixth and final meeting prior to giving the go-ahead to a project that impacts the very issues being discussed. Is the density of this project lower than others proposed? Yes. Is the high density discussion series only about units per acre? Absolutely not.
Is it okay? I don't think so.
We are asked to believe that this is a MUD (mixed use development) and not "high density". While the uses are certainly mixed, as I pointed out during the meeting this project meets neither the spirit nor the letter of the MUD zoning ordinance. Perhaps the project is close enough to the MUD rules to be approved. This may be true. But, it is not such a perfect MUD that we should permit ourselves to ignore the public discussions that very well may impact this project's final design.
The real tragedy is that this project, thoughtfully designed by Barrett Williamson and brought forward by a local investor, does so many things well. This project would have been the perfect candidate for approval under our new rules. The project hits a home run on on many things we will be asking other high density projects to do. The building's height is reasonable, the density is not overly intensive, the exterior materials are 100% durable, and the parking provided is likely adequate. We will be lucky if the other high density projects offer our community this type of quality.
Moving forward it is my hope that we will use the Boyd/Monnet project as a measuring stick for other proposals. Let's require our investors from out of town to rise to the high standards of this project. Specifically, we must demand reasonable building heights, 80 to 100% durable exterior materials, and concessions to neighbors who will be affected by the new construction.
No comments:
Post a Comment