Join the Ward 4 Email List!

Thursday, December 12, 2013

TIF Trouble #1. Buy this (basic services). Not that (water cannons).

By now you may have heard that I "took aim" at the University North Park Tax Increment Financing (TIF) district during the December 10, 2013 City Council meeting.  If you have not heard, you are welcome to read The Norman Transcript's account here: http://www.normantranscript.com/headlines/x601933874/Norman-City-Council-votes-8-1-for-job-development-measure-in-North-Park-TIF-district

While the article fairly retells a few of my comments, it continues the disservice of distracting the public from the real harm the TIF has created --the reason I spoke up.  This harm has nothing to do with unmet expectations of the public or with the wisdom of planned incentives for industry and retail.  Those issues may very well reflect past and future folly that can be chagrined and debated, respectively.  They do not represent a crisis.  The crisis is the perverted budgeting choices the TIF has created.  A few examples of these perversions: the city cut funding to our non-profit partners (because the budget was just too tight) but then authorized hundreds of thousands of dollars for rotating water cannons.  The city continues to under-fund our parks but recently approved enhanced, brick and mortar signage for the TIF retail strip center.  How did these choices happen?  How have we so easily placed luxuries ahead of basic services?

The answer is fairly simple (and appalling).  The TIF district sequesters sales tax funds that would otherwise be available in the general fund for basic services.  By placing these funds in the special TIF pool, they are not scrutinized like our general fund.  In the general fund we squeeze everything we can out of each dollar. To this end we have cut staffing, denied raises to our employees, and reduced funds to our non-profit partners.   Conversely, the TIF pool requires that its funds be used in the TIF district only; we have arbitrarily decided this is a different type of money.  In the TIF pool, the "end game" is not to squeeze the most out of our money but the opposite.  We aim to spend that money to create the spectacular!  The two pools create strange parallel budgets wherein one cuts into the meat and the other piles on the fat.

(A side note: I love great projects and I hope our Legacy Park and potential cultural facility can be just that for all of Norman and others to enjoy.  It does not mean we have to be unwise or down right cruel with our budgets.  The two projects mentioned represent only $14 million of a $52 million TIF project plan.  Who gets the remaining $38 million of SPECTACULAR!?  We can achieve the cultural facility through other means and save millions.  We are currently committed to the park.)

To be fair, this arbitrary decision to create a TIF pool is born of a somewhat logical plan: a TIF district could attract "new" sales to a city.  Thus, it might be fair to use a portion of those sales taxes to improve that district only.  Things may happen this way in other TIF districts, I don't know.  What I do know is that evidence suggests this is NOT happening in Norman.   The overwhelming majority of Norman's sales tax growth (new retail) is occurring in the TIF district; our overall sales tax revenues have not experienced any additional growth over projected sales taxes.  To state that more plainly, there is no evidence of a "bump" in sales tax revenue due to the TIF.  This means that instead of "attracting" new sales to the city, the TIF has "captured" the new sales that the city was expected to attract anyway.  And ... guess what? We desperately need that sales tax to fund city services that grow more expensive each year and are stretched more thin by a growing
population.  But that real and true NEED is unmet as the funds sit in the special TIF pool and get spent on luxuries or gifted to businesses, corporations, and developers.

In closing, I am not here to raise a single issue over a completed or contemplated TIF project.  We are likely to buy more fancy light poles, brick signage, and at least one tower of flame.  We are contemplating sending cash to successful business(es) and fancy retail stores.  I look forward to these discussions and have great faith in our city leaders to make sound decisions with your tax dollars. *** But... I have one request, end the special TIF fund pool and let these expenditures compete for your tax dollars right along side basic city services.  Let our budget reflect our values.  This is what budgets do.  Your city does not value retail luxuries over basic services --trust me.  We simply have to undo this TIF scheme to allow us to show it. ***

Gregory J. Jungman
Council Member, Ward 4
Norman, Oklahoma

4 comments:

  1. Well, damn it. I wrote a lengthy comment and when I hit Preview, it disappeared!
    This time I'll just hit Publish ... What gives?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Just a quick point of clarification. We did NOT cut funding for social agencies in the budget. In the 2014 budget we approved $424,639 and in 2013 it was $412,274 (actual was $416,556) was and in 2012 it was $357,974 (actual $377,226).

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you, Robert. I think this conversation is going to be a great discussion that only help the city. I am referring to the literal cuts we implemented in the final hours of the most recent budget. I believe we have restored those amounts now. The crisis we have is in the process. The general fund is a crucible where social services, parks, staff salaries, and other necessities are at risk of deprivation or deep cuts. The TIF Fund lives an entirely different reality where luxuries and gambles seem to make sense. We owe to ourselves (especially if the budget crisis is real) to review the situation. Your talent with numbers will be very helpful as we fight thru the details and implications.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I point is even if you take into account those final hours cuts they were still not cuts. They were a reduction in the increase. Even with the cuts we still increased funding to social services. True the TIF is a separate entity with a different purpose and a separate funding source. All of which was agreed to many years ago. Whether you consider the water canons a luxury or part of the spectacular which was promised if up to you. Remember we have an award winning park design that is coming in under budget. Again if you are truly serious about helping the city budget, hope you will take me up on my offer to sit down and discuss the TIF in more details. It can be very complicated and hard to follow. I have been involved from the very beginning in one capacity or another so I feel like a have a pretty good understanding of the facts of the history. Also keep in mind if you would have voted no on the budget (only needed one more vote)then that would have forced us to redo the budget and align our priorities with the budget. We will never get increased funding for parks till the council forces the budget to be increased for parks.

      Delete