Join the Ward 4 Email List!

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Economic Development Incentives: Can We Afford It? Should We Do It?

The morning of October 4, 2012, your City Council's Business and Community Affairs Committee engaged further discussions on a proposed ordinance that would provide incentives to certain businesses and corporations for locating to Norman.

Here are a few highlights:

O A business that brings jobs paying $33,000 per year would be eligible for cash, tax benefits, or other rewards for bringing "good jobs" to Norman. (For context, a family of three making this amount of money is eligible for free and/or reduced lunch in our school system.)

O Communities in neighboring states offer TIF incentives, tax abatement, cash, free rent, and other incentives to businesses. Norman is likely to incorporate one or all of these "tools" into our ordinance. This is real money or real debt.

Please weigh in on the Economic Development discussion. Our Norman Economic Development Authority (NEDA)has broad and powerful tools to both legally and politically to commit the city to expensive projects. I am afraid we are moving too quickly on this and without enough information.

While I don't exactly agree with this gentleman's ideas on Economic Development and tax abatement. I enjoyed the absurdity of the discussion. A clip of the City of Wichita:

1 comment:

  1. The City of Norman would give my mother nightmares. When asked for a justification of policies, for some weird reason the City always appeals to what other cities do. Give away valuable assets to businesses? Communities in neighboring states do it! Make citizens register before speaking at Council meetings? Other cities do it! I have a feeling that if Ardmore jumped off a cliff, Norman would be follow suit.

    The problem with this sort of reasoning, especially with respect to local economic development incentives, is that even though everyone uses them, no one benefits. That is what the empirical evidence says. I sent copies of 3 academic papers on this topic (available for the asking!) to the City Manager and CM Lockett - Chair of the Business and Community Affairs Committee - but I got no response.

    I am loathe to draw the conclusion, but the total lack of interest in the economic literature assessing development incentives seems to suggest, at least, that economic-development-incentives advocates do not have the interests of Norman at heart so much as the interests of the subsidized businesses. I'm not sure how to understand the City's unwillingness to look at the evidence other than to think that maybe they just don't care whether "TIF incentives, tax abatement, cash, free rent, and other incentives to businesses" pay off for the Norman community at large.

    ReplyDelete