On July 24, I asked my colleagues to allow an update to our July 10 minutes to reflect the Ciy Attorney's advice. The minutes as presented made no mention of Mr. Bryant's caution to Council that a full exemption to the WQPZ and paving improvements is possibly illegal. This is a very important fact as it represents the best legal advice available to Council when making their final decision. Other things are also affected that might be important to our citizens. I simply wanted the remarks of our attorney in the written record --factual and transparent.
The reaction from my colleagues was shocking. My request was called "ridiculous" by one Council Member. Another Council Member known to trumpet transparency, said that a change might create an inconsistency in how we create minutes. The Council (except Jim Griffith) was convinced. The Transcript writes about this debacle here: http://normantranscript.com/headlines/x318865749/Council-raises-minutes-issue .
In this case something very strange happended ... the citizens demanded transparency, and the Council responded, “That is not equal application of policy,”.
Consistency is more important than transparency? Being consistently non-transparent is just fine for Norman? This is yet another example of saying one thing and doing the opposite. And ... write it down ... the same elected officials will very soon tell you how much they value transparency and accountability in government.
I couldn't make this stuff up.
Greg
How sad to see people that you once thought highly of make these kind of value statements. For it is about their values and those that they represent. Disappointed...yes, Surprised...not really any more.
ReplyDeleteCity Council (except Jungman and Griffith) voted that the minutes should not note that a legally questionable exemption of policy (water quality protection zone and transportation impact fees) was granted because it would involve unequal application of policy!!!
ReplyDeleteOf course, the exemption was unequal application since others are obliged to follow legal requirements. Consistent inconsistency is what I enjoy most about City Council arguments.
I have a theory as to why the other council members did not want this legal advise entered into the minutes. I might be mistaken, but I believe the City Attorney mentioned that he was unsure of the legality of the whole situation and that the actual members of council who voted to approve that particular plat issue might be held legally and FINANCIALLY responsible. I think they are attempting to bury their vote away in the lengthy online video so they can claim ignorance of the law and not be held personally accountable for the financial and possible criminal damages against the citizens of Norman. That's my theory. Keep up the good work and give em hell.
ReplyDelete