Join the Ward 4 Email List!

Thursday, August 29, 2013

Lindsey Street Design Options: Resolving Safety and Traffic Issues

(sent via email on August 29, 2013; please join our email list!)

On Tuesday, September 3rd at 5:30 P.M. the Norman City Council will hold a study session and public meeting to discuss design proposals for Lindsey Street.  You have likely read ample information about this in the Norman Transcript, including the very different visions for Lindsey Street proposed.  Tuesday is a great opportunity to get more information and share your thoughts.

I also want to let you know where I stand on this issue.  I was not involved in crafting the transportation bond that funds rebuilding Lindsey Street; I am left with the reality that our city is committed to spend millions of dollars to resolve safety, traffic problems and drainage issues.  I am also well aware of the graphics used in the run-up to the bond election that showed a five lane concept with free-flowing traffic and bicycles.  Today, your City Council is faced with enacting a construction project to meet this vision.  For me, a challenge has arisen: we now know that the original vision is deeply flawed.

The safety flaw.  I feel directly responsible for the safety of citizens on projects I vote for or against.  In reviewing Lindsey Street options, I clearly see difference among the choices.  The data is clear; slower speeds are safer.   You can effectively create slower speeds by creating more modest roads.  The slower speeds also invite cyclists and pedestrians.  Would you ride in a bike lane just feet from cars driving 40 mph or more?  We also know that accidents happen overwhelmingly at the intersection.  The data is clear here as well.  Circular intersections called "roundabouts" significantly reduce all accidents as compared to signalized intersections and nearly eliminate fatality crashes.

The traffic flaw.  When a four or five lane Lindsey Street opens in 2017, cars may possibly "free-flow" and change lanes freely at speeds exceeding the posted limits (this is bad for bikes and pedestrians by the way) --essentially creating a highway feel.   This matches our promise to solve congestion, but... in 2035 (just 18 years later), engineers project that traffic will have grown along this corridor.  Vehicle traffic will likely exceed 35,000 cars per day.  Under these conditions, the intersections at McGee and Berry Road degrade back to their formerly congested status.  Other sections of the roadway are projected to be moderately congested.  My conclusion here: we might solve the Lindsey traffic problem but only for a short time.  Is a design that likely recreates the congestion it intended to solve the best design?

The "arterial" flaw.  In our 2025 Plan, Lindsey is an arterial roadway.  But arteries go important places ... where does Lindsey Street go?  Lindsey Street westbound goes to Interstate 35 --that's an important place when we need to leave town.  In the opposite direction Lindsey Street heads toward the university, but the new four or five lane plan does exactly "go" there.  There is no plan and little interest in widening past Berry Road.  The new Lindsey, as shown to bond voters, takes you to Berry Road or perhaps Imhoff Bridge and stops.  During the bond election, I considered this to be a fact of life in Norman.  You simply have congestion as cars jockey for a place on the narrow section.  Now, I believe there is a better way.

The better way is not perfectly clear at this time.  Many are rushing to judgment on issues wholly undecided.  On Tuesday, you will see and hear different visions for Lindsey.  Perhaps most importantly, you will hear that we don't have to build roads the way we always build them.  Widening a road can mean much more than just adding lanes of traffic.  We will look at safety and traffic congestion issues under the different scenarios.  We can even choose different elements of the competing plans and demand the best of both.

There is one more thing we could do.  We could, if we choose, demand construction of the initial vision --five lanes of roadway -- as planned.  That was the proposal offered during the bond election and perhaps in this case "all sales are final".  This is still a democracy (republic) after all and what people want matters.  For me to support such a notion, I would have to be certain that you understand the flaws and believe that they just do not matter.
See you at City Hall,

GREG

Gregory J. Jungman

Council Member, Ward 4
Norman, Oklahoma

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Budget Battle 2014

Another long City Council Meeting in the books!  For the record, we started with a special session at 5:00 PM and adjourned for the night at 1:00 AM.  During this time we enjoyed three or four short "bio breaks" but otherwise had our nose to the grindston for the full 8 hours.

I want to give a quick tip of the hat to City staff who no doubt started their day at 8 AM or earlier ... wow, that's a long day!

On June 11, 2013, our City Council Meeting focused largely on the FYE 2014 City Budget.  While the budget as written projects a loss of about $2 million, the city has a strong track record of earning more revenues and incurring less expenses than projected --much like this year, which began with a deficit projected but should end with a multi-million dollar surplus.  Budgets are funny like that.  They remind of a saying often attributed to Former US Army General H. Norman Schwarzkopf:  "Planning is essential but plans are useless."  You can project the future, and when things change (perhaps for the better) the original plan is out the window.

The Budget Battle included a few amendments.  Many of these amendments were routine and approved unanimously.  Others were far from routine and enjoyed vigourous debate.  I voted against three consecutive amendments that reduced the budget by various amounts.  In my view, these savings would be at the expense of city services.  In others' view, the cuts were necessary and manageable steps in the right direction.  To support the spirit of saving money, I offered my own amendment.  I suggested that we delay the hiring of a "retail marketing coordinator" for one year.  This would save the city $85,000 and not reduce services one iota.  This amendment was rejected 2 - 8 in favor of the possible benefits (some suggested real revenue benefits) of the new staff person.

Why did I reject cuts on three items, but propose and support a cut of my own?  Some suggested that this smacks of inconsistency.  I say it does not.  In all cases, I rejected budget cuts that were likely to  cut services to our citizens.  I supported the cut that would save money and not cut services.  I feel like this position is very consistent.

I would like for us to explore more cuts that save money and deliver the same level of great city services!

Tuesday, May 28, 2013

Update! High Density Public Meeting: Monday, June 3rd at 6:00 PM

Please join me at City Hall for a public meeting on the latest draft of our high density housing zoning proposal.  The meeting was previously set for Thursday, May 30, but the threat of severe weather prompted a reschedule to Monday, June 3.

The proposal is far from perfect and deviates is some significant ways from public input.  A citizen sent me this simple skematic on the possibile building sizes in comparision to a common one story and two story residential structures.

The public meeting will include brief presentations by city staff on what the new code proposes to allow and what the new code proposes to limit.  The presentations will be followed by a break-out session where citizens can interact directly with staff and ask questions in a small group setting.

It appears that the skematic is intentionally arranged to show that HD-2 is not prohibited next door a single family home (it is "discouraged" only).  And HD-3 is not prohibited or discouraged next to duplex or smaller smaller scale apartment buildings.  HD-3 is also not limited in height or density. 

I am happy to take questions by phone or email.  Ward4@NormanOK.gov
GREG

Saturday, May 11, 2013

High Density Housing Rule Changes in Advance of May 13 Committee Meeting

Update on the high density draft ordinance!  City staff changed a few numbers.  Here is what they changed and why...

HD-1
This would be townhouses or row houses built in an urban fashion (no yard).  

Originally, The developments would have a max height of 37 feet and a max density of 40 units per acre.  These projects would have flexible parking requirements within a 1 space per bedroom minimum.

Now, the max height is increased to 45 feet.  Staff found mention of a three story height limit in an industrial zoning that allowed a 45 feet height.  So they chose to use it.  I don't believe we intend to build high density housing next to industrial sites ... and I am confused as to why we would search the industrial code for parameters on residential structures. 

The code doesn't limit this category to three-story structures.  The draft code is silent on allowable stories.  So, I fear that we are welcoming fights with developers who will pursue four story heights with the flexibility of the HD-1 zone.  

HD-2
This would be apartment developments built with zero set back in a urban fashion similar to projects in OKC near Bricktown.  

Originally, The projects would have a max height of 48 feet and a max density of 75 units per acre. These projects would include mandatory structured/integrated parking or parking fees payable to the city to provide for shared parking.  Commercial uses on the first floor will be encouraged dependent on location.

Now, the max height is 55 feet.  Staff believes that a four-story structure could be as tall as 55'.  Sadly, the committee was clear that it desired the original height limit. 

HD-3 - this category was unchanged!
This would be a high rise-type category allowing construction up to the max height for frame construction of 75 feet.  Max densities would be unlimited.   Commercial uses on the first floor(s) would be required to support active street scape.  A parking garage or integrated parking deck would be required with possible parking fees to cover additional parking needs.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Picking Winners and Losers: The Pitfalls of Incentivizing Business and Industry

On the evening of April 23rd  your Norman City Council approved an economic development incentives policy and created the Economic Development Advisory Board to encourage businesses to choose Norman or expand in Norman.  The hope is that these firms will create jobs for Norman citizens and help our economy. The EDAB is specifically created to analyze the wisdom of doling out the incentives to private corporations such as cash, cash rebates, tax breaks, or other assistance.
In my view the policies needed some key improvements.  My reasons for these improvements were heard during the April 23 Council Meeting.  I truly appreciate my colleague’s commitment to listening.  The vigorous debate over my suggested changes demonstrated that my reasons were valid –in spite of being rejected.  I realize that this debate consumed much of people’s time and extended our Council meeting late into the evening.  I appreciate everyone’s patience.
For the record, my objections were two fold.  One, the new Economic Development Advisory Board and its authority to convene executive sessions creates a problem: lack of openness.  Sadly, I do not mean openness to the public, and I do not mean the board should avoid executive session.  The Oklahoma Statutes are somewhat peculiar in how they govern such private sessions.  A public body may hold one for various reasons, but members outside the public body are not eligible to “sit in” in all occasions.  Further, once an executive session is over there is no record of what transpired.  To resolve I asked that detailed written minutes be taken during these closed sessions.  This would allow members of the City Council to be informed of the discussions of the EDAB.  This would not open the process to public view --just to Council.  This suggestion was defeated 8 to 1. 
Secondly, I asked that our business recruiter-- the Norman Economic Development Coalition --be removed from the EDAB.  The ordinance includes one NEDC representative as an ex-officio member of the EDAB granting this person the right to join all sessions including executive sessions (but not vote).  The NEDC is guaranteed a seat at the table with EDAB, but Council Members do not enjoy the same right.  This is backwards, clearly. 
Further, the NEDC is asked to invite firms to Norman and encourage them to do business here.  To then ask NEDC if the firm should be provided an incentive is inappropriate.  In essence, NEDC will be grading their own work.  My amendment would have provided a clear separation of duties between recruiter and evaluator on any deal.  The amendment also harmed nothing –the EDAB could invite NEDC into any meeting it chose to, open or executive session. 
Lastly, the NEDC would benefit from the separation.  The NEDC, while publicly funded, has extensive private real estate holdings and assets.  The NEDC reported over $9 million in assets in its most recent financial statements.  Actual conflicts of interest would exist should NEDC choose to advise the EDAB on a firm with which NEDC had a partnership or financial interest.  This is unnecessary confusion for the public and bad policy for our city.  The suggestion failed 8 to 1.
I am genuinely afraid for our city on this issue.   So many cities have tried to play “the incentives game” with consequences ranging from neutral to disastrous.  I have seen zero evidence that incentives have enriched a city like ours.  Even incentives that seemingly harm nothing hurt the city by wasting valuable staff time and tying up public money or resources.  In at least one city, a local government declared bankruptcy over a failed incentive deal.  In many other cities, including those near us, public money has been spent with no discernible improvement in public well-being, financial or otherwise. 
For what it’s worth … the Norman City Council has promised to make better decisions than those councils and cities who failed.  We have pledged to be skeptics and carefully analyze every deal.  Hopefully, this comes to fruition, and Norman turns away every bad deal that comes our way.  Hopefully, we will know a bad deal when we see one.

Monday, April 22, 2013

High Density Compromise on the Table....

A remarkable shift in direction lead to some progress on the city's possible high density housing ordinance currently under consideration by the Community Planning and Transportation Committee.  Here is the run down:

The draft ordinance would create three categories of high density housing.  All categories would be required to produce a traffic impact analysis, submit to an infrastructure assessment by public works staff, and adhere to compatibility and quality design standards.  An architectural review board would help determine the merits of individual projects. The categories are as follows:

HD-1
This would be townhouses or row houses built in an urban fashion (no yard).  The developments would have a max height of 37 feet and a max density of 40 units per acre.  These projects would have flexible parking requirements within a 1 space per bedroom minimum.

HD-2
This would be apartment developments built with zero set back in a urban fashion similar to projects in OKC near Bricktown.  The projects would have a max height of 48 feet and a max density of 75 units per acre. These projects would include mandatory structured/integrated parking or parking fees payable to the city to provide for shared parking.  Commercial uses on the first floor will be encouraged dependent on location.

HD-3
This would be a high rise-type category allowing construction up to the max height for frame construction of 75 feet.  Max densities would be unlimited.   Commercial uses on the first floor(s) would be required to support active street scape.  A parking garage or integrated parking deck would be required with possible parking fees to cover additional parking needs.

What do you think?  I welcome your thoughts and feedback.  Next meeting: May 13th at 5:30pm.

GREG

Monday, March 18, 2013

Approving New Plats. Do We Have the Water?

On March 12, 2013, I voted against a residential plat including 498 residential lots or soon to be suburban homes.  The developer stated that full build out would occur over the next ten years.  I faced numerous pressures to hold my tongue and nod in favor of the request, but in the end I am confident that I cast the vote that reflects good stewardship for our community.

My vote against the plat is motivated by some simple facts.  In the summer months Norman routinely uses more water than our system can produce.  Our system production capacity is approximately 20 million gallons per day (MGD).  For the first time in anyone's memory, the City of Norman has instituted compulsory water conservation measures in winter months.  These measure were motivated by the Lake Thunderbird's governing authority, the Central Oklahoma Master Conservation District (COMCD), notifying Norman that it should plan for a 10% reduction in water allocation due to low lake levels and our current drought (picture right and above shows exposed shore line at the Lake).  The bottomline is simple: Norman routinely uses more water than it can produce and our production capacity is decreasing.

Are we at risk of running out of water for current utility customers?  The answer is probably not.  In addition to our 20 MGD production capacity, we can purchase approximately 5 - 6 MGD from the City of Oklahoma City.  This pushes are water usage capacity to 25 MGD --a consumption level that Norman has never exceed to my knowledge.  In summer months, our usage as a community can reach 22 MGD.

This is all context for my decision to vote against the plat: should the City approve all requests for new residential plats?  When will we have approved too many? Here we have a slight problem.  Currently the City of Norman has approved 4,872 residential lots that have yet to be connected to city water (Source: Plat Activity Map, City of Norman, January 2013).  These plats represent 2.2 to 2.7 MGD of water consumption in summer months (assuming average usage rates of 14,000 upto a higher rate of 16,000 gallons per day per customer).  Even without reductions in available water, these approvals alone mean we could possibly "run out" of water on certain days in the summer.  The 498 residential lots approved by Council on March 12 would use approximately .25 MGD in summer months.  This water would be readily available in non-summer months but could represent an amount over our max availability.  How far are we willing to push the water supply?  It is fair to ask existing customers to severely ration water if this trend continues?

Will my answer always be "No" on adding plats/lots to the current roster of 5,370 approved residential lots?  It will not.  My hope on this mater is quite simple.  We must end the mindset that potable water is an entitlement for new development.  We must do so, because mandatory water conservation has forced existing customers to make this same change.  Should developers come to Council with a plan to conserve water or an perhpas simply an appreciation of how their proposal impacts water availability, I would gladly reconsider my objection to further straining our water supply.

Update March 25, 2013:
How does the potential, occaisonal lack of water affect you?  Your home insurance rates will go up.  The below is from the State Insureance Commissioner:

"ISO Ratings are determined by the evaluation of:
• fire alarm and communication systems, including telephone systems, telephone lines, staffing, and dispatching systems
• the fire department, including equipment, staffing, training, and geographic distribution of fire companies
• the water supply system, including the condition and maintenance of hydrants, and the amount of available water compared with the amount needed to suppress fires"

GREG