Join the Ward 4 Email List!

Friday, October 26, 2012

Keeping Our Word

I would like to thank you my colleagues for unanimously supporting the motion to reject the Elsey Partners' request to develop high density residential housing on Boyd Street.  I would also like to thank the members of our community that came forward to voice their opinion on the matter. 

From The Oklahoman:

... the [high density residential] policies are not ready yet, said Councilman Greg Jungman, “and we've committed to our residents that we would develop guidelines. We owe it to them to complete that commitment before approving any request for high-density developments.”

Full Article by Jane Cannon

 — 
City council members say they are not ready to approve a Kansas developer's plans to build a high-rise, student-oriented apartment building near Campus Corner.


The council voted unanimously Tuesday to reject a request from Chris Elsey, of Elsey Partners of Manhattan, Kan., to create a special planning district for a block of land between Boyd and McCullough streets from Monnett Avenue to the Boyd Street railroad tracks.
Elsey said the location is ideal for a high-density housing project that would promote “walkability” to the Campus Corner retail district and the University of Oklahoma campus.

He wants to construct a six-story, 75-foot building with 250 two-bedroom apartments on five levels, with an interior parking garage on the ground level. Conceivably, the building could house more than 500 people.

Norman's zoning ordinances do not allow for such a development, limiting housing density to 26 dwelling units per acre, Planning Director Susan Connors said. Elsey's project calls for upward of 100 dwelling units per acre.

City planners are working on setting policies for that type of project, because developers increasingly are bringing such proposals to them, Connors said.

But the policies are not ready yet, said Councilman Greg Jungman, “and we've committed to our residents that we would develop guidelines. We owe it to them to complete that commitment before approving any request for high-density developments.”
Creating a special planning district would be the only way under current zoning ordinances to accommodate what Elsey wants to do, Connors said.

To approve Elsey's request would be “putting the horse before the cart,” Mayor Cindy Rosenthal said. “We've got a land-use change suggested with no zoning request accompanying it so we can see what we would be getting. It's like being asked to write a blank check.”

Resident Cheryl Clayton said the mass and size of the building being proposed is out of proportion to its Campus Corner surroundings and would have an adverse effect on traffic, as well as aesthetics.

Elsey said he has built similar high-rise apartment buildings near Kansas State University in Manhattan and Oklahoma State University in Stillwater, and such projects are in demand because of growing student populations.

Rosenthal said Elsey's pictures “don't resemble anything like we talked about” in a series of public meetings held in June on high-density developments. At those meetings, residents looked at designs that incorporated unusual architectural elements and often featured high-rise apartments combined with retail establishments.

Councilman Jim Griffith said he was “excited” about the possibilities of mixed-use, high-density developments but couldn't support giving Elsey's project the go-ahead until guidelines for such projects are in place. He said Elsey could resubmit his project for approval later.

From the source: http://newsok.com/norman-city-council-rejects-high-density-housing-proposal/article/3721952#ixzz2APYOkgQp



Thursday, October 18, 2012

Developers are coming before City Council to ask approval of high density housing projects on Campus Corner.

Key Facts for October 23:

O October 23rd, the Elsey Partners of Manhattan, KS bring forward a proposal on Boyd at the RR tracks
O This proposal was postponed in the spring to make time for new rules on high density
O The proposed project includes approximately 300 units and is five to six stories tall

The Elsey proposal is a little different than your standard development deal.  On October 23, Elsey Partners request only an amendment or our 2025 Land Use Plan.  The amendment would create a special planning area on the "block" bound by Boyd, Monnett, McCullough, and the RR Tracks.  The special planning area would come with a special set of rules for future development that are likely unique to this area (and do not reflect our new high density zoning rules, which are forthcoming).  Then, at a later date Elsey Partners would come back to Council requesting a PUD to build their 300-unit (approx) apartment complex.

Key Facts for November 13:

O On November 16th, Mark Risser of Dallas, TX,  will bring forward a rezoning request for property generally located at Asp Avenue and Duffy Street
O Mr. Risser requests a C-3 Zoning (Intensive Commercial District) with a Special Use for a Mixed Building
O This zoning comes with no height restrictions and permits "one or more dwelling units on the upper floors"
O Mr. Risser proposes approximately 200 units in six stories at a height of 72 feet.
O The requested zoning change would permit Mr. Risser to change his plans at any point so long as he retained a commercial use on the first floor.  Mr. Risser or future owners could increase the height of the building or eliminate parking as a matter of right.

The image below is provided (I am told) by Mr. Risser as a theoretical representation of his proposal.  The picture is not drawn to scale as McFarlin seems to tower over the complex.  When in fact the apartment complex is approximately the same height as the church.


Regardless of how you feel about high density housing, I hope you will agree that completing our community process of crafting an ordinance should occur first.  Approving any project at this point would simply put the cart before the horse.

Monday, October 15, 2012

In-E-Quality: Quality Jobs Program morphs into easy money source for those who know the game


Published: 17-Apr-2012 

Eighteen years in, Oklahoma’s economic development crown jewel, the Quality Jobs Program, has strayed far afield, costing taxpayers much more than originally intended and paying out much more per job in many cases.

The information was gleaned by CapitolBeatOK from open records sources and web resources, as well as Oklahoma Department of Commerce and Oklahoma Tax Commission personnel familiar with the program or directly involved in its administration.

Oklahoma City Chamber President Roy Williams said a few months ago that QJP is a huge success, creating over $768 million in new payroll since its early 1990s launch.

But since QJP began, guidelines have become far more generous, and the state in many cases is paying more per job than it should have to – certainly more than once envisioned.

The program provides cash rebates of up to five percent of new payroll to new and existing companies for creating new jobs.
The contract can last for up to 10 years if $2.5 million in new payroll is created within three years.

But amendments to the law or Commerce Department decisions have relaxed the $2.5 millionthreshold for many recipients, records show.

The original legislative intent of the program was to support the start-up of viable business programs or companies that would create new jobs, attract new corporations, promote sales of Oklahoma products and services and provide workers health benefits.

In some cases, it has worked well. But many reincarnations and amendments in the law later, it appears it has become an easy way to “take the money and run.” (See the complete chart of QJP participants in the chart accompanying this story.)


Would Oklahoma’s taxpayers be happy if they knew:

Oklahoma paid $6.5 million to underwrite Wal-Mart pharmacy jobs around the state?

Oklahoma pays quality jobs cash to companies as they’re going belly-up, laying off workers or vacating the state – and it’s crystal clear that’s the case?

Oklahoma makes no effort to recapture money in response to overblown job projections? There is is too much temptation to project large job predictions because incentive payment calculations take this into account. And, there are no penalties or disincentives for failure to meet the projections. In fact, it could be said companies are financially rewarded for at least three years for doing so.

Oklahoma paid $3.5 million to one Tulsa company projected to create 3,000 jobs and five years later, it listed 15 jobs in that program? That’s $233,000 per job.

A company has a good shot at re-enrolling for multiple 10-year contracts by simply by creating a new legal entity. Repeated failures to meet the jobs targets appear to matter little.

Numerous companies never make it past the three year ramp-up phase because they either failed to hit payroll targets or for other reasons of their own.

Indeed, numbers tell the story. Many QJP proposals to the Oklahoma Department of Commerce include vastly overblown new jobs predictions.

It isn’t until after three years that payments are directly tied to actual jobs.

No matter how many or how few jobs the company creates it gets to keep all the cash from the first three years. 

It is very difficult for a company to ramp-up a new program in less than three years according to Commerce’s division director for policy, research and economic analysis, Deidre Myers.

Every Quality Jobs participant goes through a “rigorous process” of analysis by Commerce officials to make sure their proposals are viable, Myers said.

“It’s impossible to know how a company will perform over 10 years,” Myers said. “There are a limited number of companies that are not going to be able to complete their contract because of economic reasons. That is normal and we expect that.”

She said the number of jobs under contract with Commerce and the number of jobs a company publicly announces may be different, but didn’t elaborate on that somewhat puzzling observation.

Though the law charges Commerce and the tax commission with jointly overseeing and determining proposal viability, one tax commission official who insisted on anonymity said, “The Commerce Department just sends us a list of who to send checks to. That’s the extent of our involvement.”

Though requirements are certainly more lax now, one goal has been consistent according to one Commerce official: that the money paid out not exceed the benefits to the state.

Commerce Department QJP program administrator Richard Schwalbach assures that the program is indeed revenue positive and that payroll is monitored closely. He said after ramp-up, no money is paid out unless the jobs are actually on the participant’s payroll.

He defends imposing no “clawback” provisions, saying companies would avoid doing business in Oklahoma if faced with such risks. Clawbacks would return some or all taxpayer money if jobs aren’t created, the company goes belly-up or leaves the state.

A look at the Oklahoma Tax Commission chart shows companies having to exit the program for failing to hit target numbers, while others remain in. Numerous others drop out voluntarily. But they kept every dime of the ramp-up money.

Guidelines seem to have been loosened by lawmakers such that the $2.5 million payroll thresholddoesn’t apply to many manufacturer classifications anymore.

But around the country, The City Sentinel found the same trends. Few companies are held accountable. And fewer still are monitored by outside agencies of officials, according to a study bywww.goodjobs.org.

Goodjobsfirst.com is a corporate subsidy tracker search engine. The hosting group collects data to help promote accountable economic growth across the nation.

QJP’s guidelines have placed it in the middle of failing or dying company dramas many times, as well as companies exiting the state in a hurry.

The Great Plains Airlines fiasco is one example. Branded by experts as ill-conceived and doomed from the start, the Oklahoma Legislature ultimately coughed up an estimated $28 million for the venture, which failed heading into 2004. That was also the year the QJP gave the airline $336,000.

The downfall didn’t just hurt taxpayers. Bank of Oklahoma stepped up in good faith, lending $7 million to assist the venture, only to lose it several years later.

Weatherford’s Imation Corp. announced it was closing in early 2010. Several months later, it received$78,000 in Quality Jobs checks. In 2011, Commerce gave Imation another $109,309.

Commercial Financial Services received over $9 million in QJP money over nearly 10 years, then collapsed into a bankruptcy blaze in 1999. After dodging prison time over criminal allegations, the company president has re-enrolled in QJP, but has yet to file a claim for any cash rebates, records show.

Dell Computer Corp. came to town in 2005. It began laying off in 2008 and is now 500 below its original public jobs announcement. It has received about $19 million in QJP incentives.

In cases such as Dell, is the state delaying the inevitable, propping up companies at great cost to taxpayers -- buying time?  It remains to be seen.

Meyers said the program works as lawmakers have structured it and Commerce is simply carrying out its directive.

“I would not assume I know better than legislators how to formulate this incentive program,” she said. “The Department of Commerce simply implements the program. Right now we administer the program according to the law and according to the best of our ability.”

Clearly, there are companies that have enrolled in QJP with viable business proposals and have – and are making -- earnest efforts to reach targets. And many are creating jobs with staying power.

 ***

taken from the original source: http://capitolbeatok.com/reports/in-e-quality-quality-jobs-program-morphs-into-easy-money-source-for-those-who-know-the-game

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

TIME November 9, 1998: Corporate Welfare


A TIME investigation uncovers how hundreds of companies get on the dole--and why it costs every working American the equivalent of two weeks' pay every year


By Donald L. Barlett and James B. Steele

TIME magazine
(TIME, Nov. 9 [1998]) -- How would you like to pay only a quarter of the real estate taxes you owe on your home? And buy everything for the next 10 years without spending a single penny in sales tax? Keep a chunk of your paycheck free of income taxes? Have the city in which you live lend you money at rates cheaper than any bank charges? Then have the same city install free water and sewer lines to your house, offer you a perpetual discount on utility bills--and top it all off by landscaping your front yard at no charge?

Fat chance. You can't get any of that, of course. But if you live almost anywhere in America, all around you are taxpayers getting deals like this. These taxpayers are called corporations, and their deals are usually trumpeted as "economic development" or "public-private partnerships." But a better name is corporate welfare. 

The justification for much of this [corporate] welfare is that the U.S. government is creating jobs. Over the past six years, Congress appropriated $5 billion to run the Export-Import Bank of the United States, which subsidizes companies that sell goods abroad. 

State and local governments now give corporations money to move from one city to another--even from one building to another--and tax credits for hiring new employees. They supply funds to train workers or pay part of their wages while they are in training, and provide scientific and engineering assistance to solve workplace technical problems. They repave existing roads and build new ones. They lend money at bargain-basement interest rates to erect plants or buy equipment. They excuse corporations from paying sales and property taxes and relieve them from taxes on investment income.

This kind of arithmetic seldom adds up. Let's say the Philadelphia job pays $50,000. And each new worker pays $6,700 in local and state taxes. That means it will take nearly a half-century of tax collections from each individual to earn back the money granted to create his or her job. And that assumes all 950 workers will be recruited from outside Philadelphia and will relocate in the city, rather than move from existing jobs within the city, where they are already paying taxes.

If corporate welfare is an unproductive end game, why does it keep growing in a period of intensive government cost cutting? For starters, it has good p.r. and an army of bureaucrats working to expand it.  They have their own trade associations. They create attractive websites on the Internet. And they never call it "welfare." They call it "economic incentives" or "empowerment zones" or "enterprise zones."

Whatever the name, the result is the same. Some companies receive public services at reduced rates, while all others pay the full cost. Some companies are excused from paying all or a portion of their taxes due, while all others must pay the full amount imposed by law. Some companies receive grants, low-interest loans and other subsidies, while all others must fend for themselves.

In the end, that's corporate welfare's greatest flaw. It's unfair. One role of government is to help ensure a level playing field for people and businesses. Corporate welfare does just the opposite. It tilts the playing field in favor of the largest or the most politically influential or most aggressive businesses. In the next story, and those that follow in the coming weeks, you will meet the beneficiaries of corporate welfare--and the people who pay for it.


Thank you to Charles Wesner of Norman, OK for drawing my attention to this important article.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Economic Development Incentives: Can We Afford It? Should We Do It?

The morning of October 4, 2012, your City Council's Business and Community Affairs Committee engaged further discussions on a proposed ordinance that would provide incentives to certain businesses and corporations for locating to Norman.

Here are a few highlights:

O A business that brings jobs paying $33,000 per year would be eligible for cash, tax benefits, or other rewards for bringing "good jobs" to Norman. (For context, a family of three making this amount of money is eligible for free and/or reduced lunch in our school system.)

O Communities in neighboring states offer TIF incentives, tax abatement, cash, free rent, and other incentives to businesses. Norman is likely to incorporate one or all of these "tools" into our ordinance. This is real money or real debt.

Please weigh in on the Economic Development discussion. Our Norman Economic Development Authority (NEDA)has broad and powerful tools to both legally and politically to commit the city to expensive projects. I am afraid we are moving too quickly on this and without enough information.

While I don't exactly agree with this gentleman's ideas on Economic Development and tax abatement. I enjoyed the absurdity of the discussion. A clip of the City of Wichita:

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

August 28th: A Proud Day, Norman Approves Greenway Master Plan

There are so many people to thank, and since my involvement in the Greenway Master Plan and Greenbelt Commission is so limited, I don't even know who all to say "thank you" to.  So, let me thank everyone --everyone that pitched in along the way to create a plan that works for all of Norman.

This plan, an aspiration for our community, is one that has the blessing of every corner of our community.  The development community supports it.  Those who prioritize ecology and sustainability support it. And pretty much everyone in between is on board.

I also want to call particular attention to Council Member Dave Spaulding.  CM Spaulding and I may not always I agree, but I admire and respect Dave's openness to new information --even when that information may not jive with his deeply held beliefs.  This is the second time in less than a year that I have personally witnessed CM Spaulding listen to views not aligned with his own and find a way forward.  While CM Spaulding could not in the vote for the plan, he kindly withdrew his motion to further postpone its consideration.

Of course, we are only beginning our journey to fulfill the vision of our Greenbelt Commission.  The next step, finding resources to make the plan a reality, will require the city to redouble its efforts.  Groups with very different interests will have sit across the table and build upon the common ground established in this plan.  Taking this vision and making it a reality will not be easy, but nothing worthwhile ever is.

This is progress. Thank you, Norman.

Learn more about the Greenbelt Commission and the Greenway Master plan here:
http://normanok.gov/planning/greenbelt-commission

What is possible?  The City of Flagstaff, Arizona has an extensive system of urban, wild, bike, and hiking trails.  Check their system map: http://az-flagstaff3.civicplus.com/index.aspx?NID=1521

-GREG